Does the UK Tax Regime Distort the Housing Market?

By: Lucent Group   02/19/2016
Keywords: Estate Brokers, Investment Homes, Relocation Specialist

Part of how cities and towns accept new housing is through improvements in nearby infrastructure. But how that is assessed fairly is subject to debate.

The UK’s housing shortage problem is one with arguably many causes. Some trace it back to Thatcherism, selling off council housing without guaranteeing that affordable housing would be built to take its place. Others say the planning system, the preservation of green fields, tight financing rules, and the Great Recession of 2008-2010 (and later) all shook out buyers as well as builders.

Now with a resurgent economy, investors involved in strategic land development are betting on building and selling more houses to a country that clearly demands them. They work through and past the planning authorities, select homebuilders to construct houses, and they generally do well when a development is complete. But there still are certain stymying issues.

A good case can be made for the market distortions that some tax structures cause. One example of this is how the Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) affects the price and liquidity of home ownership. On a home valued at under £125,000, there is no tax but until December 2014 there were incremental jumps to a 2% tax (£125,001 to £250,000), 5% tax (£150,000 to £925,000) on up to 12% for homes valued at £1.5 million on up. Those abrupt jumps created artificial reasons for holding down prices and therefore the types of homes that were built were often done so to stay below a SDLT threshold. Critics point out this “slab” system tax was designed in 2000, before the 139 per cent increase in average UK home prices that we have today. A new, incremental rate is progressive but gradual.

Other taxes imposed on developers can also dampen development. When joint venture partnerships form to convert land to housing - in all that entails - investors and builders have to budget for other costs as well:

Planning gain taxes - The objective of land investment funds applied to development is to be granted planning permission to build on land that was previously designated for a lesser (lower value) purpose. Planning gain taxes divert some of this gain to the public sector, which can be a fair way of funding public realm improvements. Some parties are critical of this system, saying the negotiation between developers and planning authorities can be wrought with inconsistency, unfairness, a lack of transparency and lengthy negotiations.

Community Infrastructure Levy - Councils in England and Wales can raise funds for infrastructure from private developers to support public development. It is charged on a per-square-metre of development basis. The benefit to developers of this system (versus planning gain taxes) is that the fee structure is established up front, applicable to all developers without a horse-trading process of negotiations. Planning Resource, an independent planning professionals intelligence firm, provides a current list of CIL charges for developments across the country.

But not all infrastructural improvements are compulsory. Land investors and developers who are strategic land specialists might voluntarily propose and build infrastructure around developments. To do so the developers need to have a fairly good margin on their project.

Individuals and institutions alike look to developers to create value from undervalued land. But all investors are wise to consult with an independent financial advisor for advice on where and how to invest real estate funds.

Keywords: Buyer Broker, Estate Brokers, Home Locator, Investment Homes, Land Investment, Land Management, Property Investment, Real Estate Listing Service, Relocation Specialist

Other news and updates from Lucent Group


Has Localism Failed? Osborne Gets Tough on Local Planning Authorities

The post-election proposals from the Conservative Government seem to buck the trend of the 2011 Localism Act. Local councils need


Detached Home Building is Up in the UK: What are the Implications?

Detached homes are in high demand in Britain by “second stepper” buyers upgrading from their first homes. One step up


CBI on the UK Housing Shortage: It’s Bad for Business

The million-plus homes deficit in Britain is treated like a social issue. It is that but so much more; leading


Building Upward: How the British Feel About High Rise Living

The squeeze is on as the British population continues to increase. London is in a tall building boom, but not


Are Newly-Built Homes in the UK More Sustainable?

Indeed they are. But whether new builds or retrofits, increasing the energy efficiency of homes is beneficial to the UK


What Effect Has the Stamp Duty Overhaul Had on Homebuilding in the UK?

Lowering the “slab stamp tax” was readily welcomed in all quarters – especially young buyers, homebuilders and investors. New building


How Effective Might the Help-To-Buy ISA Be for First Time Buyers?

Younger working adults in the UK struggle to buy homes, largely because a deposit is hard to save. This programme


Does the Conservatives’ 2015 Victory Mean More Houses Will Be Built?

The fear of a mansion tax and general uncertainty preceding the May election stalled house sales and building. Prices have


Lucent Group Announces Planning Award Nominations for Lincolnshire Lakes Development in North Lincol

Lucent Group, a land site assembly specialist, has been shortlisted for two prestigious Planning Awards for their Lincolnshire Lakes development


Lucent Group Secures Planning Approval for Hundreds of New Homes in Workington, Allerdale

Plans for one of the largest housing developments to be built in Workington in recent years have been approved by


Could the Empty Homes in England Fix the Housing Shortage?

There are hundreds of thousands of houses and flats that sit empty in the UK for various reasons. Some might


What UK Land Investors Should Know About Strategic Land Investments

Strategic land stands alone among land investments. It answers the pressing need for home building by increasing land designated for


What are Joint Venture Partnerships?

The collaboration of talent and capital is, arguably, what makes the world go around. JVPs in strategic land development are


The Various Roles in UK Joint Venture Land Investments

The advantages of investing through a joint venture partnership include reducing risk and acquiring the knowledge and skills of other