Supreme Court Requests Compromise Options in ACA Contraception Case

Supreme Court Requests Compromise Options in ACA Contraception Case from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk

By: Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk  03/31/2016
Keywords: Supreme Court, Group Health Insurance, Health Care Plans

In Zubik v. Burwell, the U.S. Supreme Court is considering whether the rights of religiously affiliated nonprofit organizations are violated by the Affordable Care Act’s contraceptive-coverage mandate. Given the sensitive, often contentious issues raised in this case, the public is anxiously awaiting the Court’s decision. However, many were surprised when less than a week after hearing oral arguments, the Court ordered the parties to provide potential compromise solutions. The ACA generally requires group health insurance plans to cover preventive care and screenings for women without cost sharing elements (copayment, coinsurance, deductible), including all contraceptive methods approved by the Food and Drug Administration. Though generally mandatory for nonprofit employers with no religious affiliation and for-profit employers that are not closely-held (the Hobby Lobby case), religious and religiously affiliated employers can avoid the contraceptive-coverage mandate, either by exemption or accommodation. Exemption. Federal regulations authorize an exemption for nonprofit religious employers, including churches and their integrated auxiliaries. These employers are not bound by the contraceptive-coverage mandate. Their employees and dependents do not have guaranteed contraceptive coverage. Accommodation. Religiously affiliated nonprofit corporations may obtain an accommodation that relieves them from complying with the mandate. These employers must notify their insurance company, third-party administrator or the Department of Health and Human Services of their religious objections to providing insurance coverage for contraceptives. Under the ACA, religious employers are exempt from the mandate, but religiously affiliated employers must take steps to obtain an accommodation. Nevertheless, these employers are not required to contract, arrange or pay for contraceptive coverage. According to the Secretary of Health and Human Services (Burwell), the regulatory process to obtain an accommodation does not substantially burden religiously affiliated employers seeking to avoid the mandate. Though some of the employers in Zubik are entitled to an accommodation, they argue that the process itself violates their sincerely held religious beliefs. According to these employers, complying with the regulatory mechanism to obtain an accommodation would make them “complicit in providing contraceptive coverage” in violation of their religion. The passing of Justice Scalia leaves only eight justices to decide this case. Many believe they are evenly divided. In the event of a 4-4- tie, the lower court rulings would remain intact, which could lead to inconsistent application of the law nationally because the Zubik case is actually a consolidation of several different cases from across the country. Perhaps this explains why the Court issued an order directing the parties to discuss ways to reach an acceptable compromise. We may never know for sure why the Court did this, but it will be interesting to see if this exercise produces any results. Fortunately, we shouldn’t have to wait long because the Court didn’t give the parties much time. All briefs must be filed by April 20, 2016. Stay tuned… At Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk, we are committed to guiding you through the constantly changing health care landscape. In addition to our other valuable risk management solutions, Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk has an online tool to help clients complete their ACA information reports. Please contact us if you have any questions or would like to discuss how we can help you comply with health care reform.

Keywords: Affordable Care Act, Group Health Insurance, Health Care Plans, Supreme Court

Contact Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk

Email

Print this page

Other news and updates from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk

Did You Get the Text About Distracted Driving Awareness Month? from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
04/07/2016

Did You Get the Text About Distracted Driving Awareness Month?

Did you know that April is National Distracted Driving Awareness Month? If not, it’s time to take notice. According to


Does Your Business Need a USDOT or MC Number? from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
03/18/2016

Does Your Business Need a USDOT or MC Number?

You may need commercial auto insurance, if you drive for any form of compensation.


Is Telemdicine Right for Your Business? from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
02/29/2016

Is Telemdicine Right for Your Business?

Industry experts estimate that 80% of employers will offer telemedicine by 2018. So what exactly is this trending health care


10 Ways to save on your Auto Insurance from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
02/18/2016

10 Ways to save on your Auto Insurance

If you want to save money (and c'mon, who doesn't want that), check out our post on Auto Savings!



Automatic Deadline Extensions Now Available for Affordable Care Act Information Reports from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
10/15/2015

Automatic Deadline Extensions Now Available for Affordable Care Act Information Reports

For the first time, all applicable large employers must comply with the Affordable Care Act’s annual healthcare reporting requirements. Employers that averaged at least 50 full-time or full-time equivalent employees in 2014 must report specific 2015 healthcare information to the Internal Revenue Service. Reports for calendar year 2015 are due in early 2016, so time is running out. Or is it?


Are You Protecting Customers’ Credit and Debit Card Data? from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
12/17/2014

Are You Protecting Customers’ Credit and Debit Card Data?

To reduce the chances of making the list in 2015, preventative measures must be taken by every business that accepts credit and debit card payments.


Understanding Excepted Benefits Under the Affordable Care Act from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
12/10/2014

Understanding Excepted Benefits Under the Affordable Care Act

Though some of these benefits, like pre-paid legal service plans, are clearly not health-related, others may provide employees with some health-related benefits.


Steps To take After a Car Accident from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
12/04/2014

Steps To take After a Car Accident

According to the Insurance Information Institute, drivers should take the following steps immediately after an accident:


Office Holiday Parties: Revel without Regret from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
11/20/2014

Office Holiday Parties: Revel without Regret

Though holiday parties can create a positive work environment, increase employee morale and promote teamwork, they can also expose employers to a number of potentially significant risks.


Protecting Against Emerging Data Security Threats from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
11/05/2014

Protecting Against Emerging Data Security Threats

With breaches becoming more common and more expensive, businesses are now discovering that steps must be taken to protect against data security breaches.


How Can Safety Reduce Workers’ Compensation Insurance Premiums? from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
10/15/2014

How Can Safety Reduce Workers’ Compensation Insurance Premiums?

Workers’ compensation insurance provides indemnity and medical benefits to employees injured on the job.


A New Right of Access for Condominium Associations from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
10/09/2014

A New Right of Access for Condominium Associations

Sometimes a condominium association needs to enter an owner’s unit, which is why Florida’s Condominium Act gives associations an irrevocable right of access.


OSHA Issues New Reporting and Recordkeeping Rules from Setnor Byer Insurance & Risk thumbnail
10/02/2014

OSHA Issues New Reporting and Recordkeeping Rules

Employers will soon have new rules to follow after experiencing workplace injuries and illnesses.