The ‘Value’ of Market Valuations in Business Litigation

The ‘Value’ of Market Valuations in Business Litigation from Roberts Means, LLC

By: Roberts Means, LLC  07/08/2014
Keywords: Law, Divorce Attorney, Business Litigation

Owners of a closely-held corporation or a small business are quick to know the current value of their home, cars, fine jewelry, or even a cherished painting. But they tend to pay much less attention to the current value of their business – at least until it is time to sell. 

However, there are many reasons to have a firm grasp on the fair market value of your company. Here are just a few examples of matters which may require a reliable and up-to-date business valuation:

  • Tracking the growth and performance of your business
  • Strengthening leverage with creditors
  • Attracting potential investors
  • Business succession
  • Family estate planning

Just as a business valuation may be critical during a divorce proceeding in accounting marital assets, market valuations have become increasingly important in business litigation, such as shareholder disputes. Recent case law has paved the way for Indiana trial courts to freely determine a company’s value based on the analysis of expert witnesses. But what’s more, in reviewing a freeze-out case involving minority shareholders’ claims against the majority owner, the Indiana court of appeals held that a trial court was right to consider the same forward-looking factors – e.g., market factors, prospective business expansion, and increased efficiencies – which a business valuator would use to determine the fair value of a company outside of a litigation context. Lees Inns of America, Inc. v. Lee, 924 N.E.2d 143 (Ind. Ct. App. 2010).In that case, the trial court had rejected the majority shareholder’s argument that a valuation of the minority shareholder’s interest should be devoid of speculation and thus confined to an analysis of the company’s historical financial performance. Id. at 156.

Indiana law generally disfavors an award of damages that are deemed too speculative in nature. So, the Indiana court of appeals’ endorsement of the trial court’s use of financial projections and future elements in a discounted cash flow approach to business valuation in the Lees Inns case is an important one to keep in mind when approaching disputes between shareholders. This may apply to litigation involving freeze-out or squeeze-out claims, a shareholder’s breach of fiduciary duty, and minority shareholder dissenter’s rights claims. 

Robert Means, LLC represents closely-held corporations and their individual owners in disputes arising amongst shareholders or between minority shareholders and the company itself, whether or not a lawsuit has been filed or is imminent. As a small firm, Robert Means, LLC is able to provide cost-effective legal advice and the level of responsive service that small business owners expect and deserve. Please feel free to call us today at (317) 353-3600 or contact us via email to discuss your case.

Keywords: Business Litigation, Divorce Attorney, Law, Local Lawyer

Other news and updates from Roberts Means, LLC

02/26/2015

Divorce and Division of a Business Interest

One of the most challenging aspects of some divorce cases is when one or both spouses own all or part


Preparing For Divorce: Custody and Parenting Time from Roberts Means, LLC thumbnail
02/26/2015

Preparing For Divorce: Custody and Parenting Time

As we discussed in our previous post, in the same way you prepare for your wedding, in the event divorce


Preparing For Divorce: Financial Concerns from Roberts Means, LLC thumbnail
02/26/2015

Preparing For Divorce: Financial Concerns

There are preparations one goes through when getting married. Once the proposal has been made and accepted, everything from the


Relocation Litigation – The Hearing from Roberts Means, LLC thumbnail
10/29/2014

Relocation Litigation – The Hearing

In our prior posts on relocation, we addressed the necessity of filing a Notice of Intent to Relocate if you intend to move and the information that must be set forth in your Notice; and also addressed the basics of relocation litigation. In this post, we’ll discuss potential evidence each parent may present to the court in a relocation hearing.


Relocation Litigation – The Basics from Roberts Means, LLC thumbnail
10/29/2014

Relocation Litigation – The Basics

If a non-relocating parent objects to your proposed move, then the court gets involved. As an initial matter, it is important to be aware of what the court can and cannot do. The court cannot prevent you from moving. The court can prevent you from moving with your children. The heart of any relocation case is where the children are going to live.


What is a Notice of Intent to Relocate? from Roberts Means, LLC thumbnail
10/29/2014

What is a Notice of Intent to Relocate?

This is the first in a series of family law posts that will address relocation. A common and unintentional misstep made by individuals with children occurs when they move. If you have children and intend to move, it is important to be aware of an Indiana law applying to your situation.


08/22/2014

Alex Lloyd Returns to CRP Racing

After a strong debut at the Pirelli World Challenge Mid-Ohio Grand Prix two weeks ago, Alex Lloyd will once again pilot the CRP Corvette under new sponsorship, RobertsMeans.com, at the Sonoma Grand Prix this weekend...


08/22/2014

Legal Custody – Joint vs. Sole

Family disputes can be emotionally and financially exhausting - especially when children are involved. Today we'll discuss how the court determines legal custody and what that could mean for you.


Child Custody – The Basics of Legal Custody from Roberts Means, LLC thumbnail
07/25/2014

Child Custody – The Basics of Legal Custody

Legal custody can be summed up as follows: Who makes the big decisions? Call Roberts Means, LLC at 317-353-3600 or contact us via email if you have any questions concerning the custody of your child.


Child Custody – The Basics of Physical Custody from Roberts Means, LLC thumbnail
07/23/2014

Child Custody – The Basics of Physical Custody

The two elements to child custody are physical custody and legal custody. Physical custody can be summarized as to which parent the child will spend the night with and when. Under the umbrella of physical custody, the options are joint/equal custody, and primary physical custody to one parent.


Child Custody and Keeping Good Records from Roberts Means, LLC thumbnail
07/02/2014

Child Custody and Keeping Good Records

When custody of your child is in dispute and it is necessary for a judge to make the final decision, it is critical that you have evidence to support your position.